The Loadout Room
Menu
  • Shooting
        • Pistol
        • Pistol Accessories
        • Rifle
        • Rifle Accessories
        • Shotgun
        • Machine Guns
        • Air Guns
        • Ammunition
        • Optics and Sights
        • Weapon Lights
        • Tips & How-To
        • Concealed Carry
        • Holsters
        • Suppressors
        • Precision Rifle Shooting
        • Firearms Training
        • 1A Gun to Ride the River With: The Smith & Wesson 686
        • The Tristar folding shotgun is ready for your wilderness adventuresThe Tristar folding shotgun is ready for your wilderness adventures
        • maxim defense cqb stock (8)The Maxim Defense CQB Stock: Short and Sweet
        • Perfecting your zero | A little help goes a LONG wayPerfecting your zero | A little help goes a LONG way
    • Close
  • Gear Reviews
      • Mission Gear
      • Camping Gear
      • Survival Gear
      • Medical Gear
      • Adventure & Travel
      • Knives & Tools
      • Overland
      • Disaster Preparedness
      • Footwear
      • Womens Gear & Clothing
        • RIP-MVehicle Preparedness: Fast access to essential items | Grey Man Tactical RIP-M
        • Midland radioOverland Essential | Midland Radio MXT275 | GXT1000
        • ppGrab your gear and go | Here’s everything you’d need to build an adventure go bag
        • Scrubba Washbag: Keep your clothes clean in the fieldScrubba Washbag: Keep your clothes clean in the field
    • Close
  • Men’s Lifestyle
      • Fitness
      • EDC
      • Eyewear
      • Watches
      • Electronics & Technology
      • Downtime
      • Mens Clothing & Accessories
      • Manly Skills
      • Style & Grooming
      • Gentleman Drinks
      • Crate Club
        • The Outdoor Edge ParaClaw: A concealed stingerThe Outdoor Edge ParaClaw: A concealed stinger
        • How to determine how long you have before the sun setsHow to determine how long you have before the sun sets
        • fireWilderness survival expert breaks down how to build a fire
        • 5.11 Tactical Expedition Long Sleeve Shirt5.11 Tactical Expedition Long Sleeve Shirt, SWAT Tested and Approved
    • Close
  • News
  • Video Demo
  • Shop

Why Traditional Martial Arts Are Not Designed for Modern Self-Defense

Why Traditional Martial Arts Are Not Designed for Modern Self-Defense

January 20, 2018 by Loadout Room Guest Authors Leave a Comment

I have studied traditional martial arts for the last 42 years; I started training in 1974. Unfortunately, however, I found them to be ineffective most of the time once I started my professional security and law enforcement career in 1988.

Please do not misunderstand my position; I love and still teach traditional martial arts every week but I always keep them in perspective to what they actually teach a person to do. I explain the difference between cultural and traditional martial arts and their purposes and true modern-day, evolved, and well-rounded fighting systems such as Pramek Adaptive Combatives (Pramek.com/pramekflorida.com/pramekdetroit.com), Modern American Combatives (palmbeachcombatives.com), Combat SAMBO, Krav Maga, Fairbairn Combatives as taught by Damian Ross of the Self Defense Company (https://www.myselfdefensetraining.com) and others.

Fighting systems of the 21st century need to include both utilization and defenses against modern weapons as well as use the latest in bio-mechanical and scientific research to improve on their effectiveness and efficiency.

I encourage any concerned citizen to study some type of martial arts or combatives to prepare themselves mentally and physical for a use-of-force situation. You meet some like-minded individuals and can learn from all of them. I have been very fortunate to learn from some of the best real-life operators and tactical law enforcement officers that exist. It is amazing what human beings can train to do and to overcome. You can be one of those people with dedication and a good choice in combative systems and instructors.

What traditional and cultural martial arts are useful for:

Discipline, kinesthetic awareness, fitness, flexibility, limited real-life practical self-defense, how to take a strong punch or kick (in some systems), conditioning

What they are not so useful for:

Adaptive Realistic fighting in a modern operational or street environment, combatives, self-defense, operational defensive countermeasures, police defensive tactics, real force on force training in a realistic environment with fully resisting attackers, using modern weapon systems and defenses against them

So, again, please understand I have the deepest respect for traditional martial arts and have studied and been ranked in many of them; however, we must understand that they are not meant to teach high percentage (effective 90% of the time against 90% of the people) and high incapacitation rate concepts that can be adapted using gross motor skills and applied universally in a modern street or operational environment.


Author – Dr. John M. Landry, Ph.D. (State Law Enforcement Detective Lieutenant – Retired). Dr. Landry has served as a police instructor since 1995, and is certified as a Field Training Officer, Firearms Instructor (Rifles-Shotguns-Pistols), General Topic Instructor, Defensive Tactics Instructor, TASER Instructor, Chemical Weapons Instructor, Impact Weapon Instructor, Firearm Retention Instructor, Handcuffing Instructor, and Reality Based Training Instructor. Dr. Landry has also trained with some of the best instructors in martial arts, firearms, and combatives to include the Crucible’s Iraq Pre-deployment course.

*Image courtesy of army.mil

Share This

Filed Under: Op-Ed Tagged With: combatives, CQB, Defensive Tactics, Martial Arts, self defense, street fight

More From The Loadout Room

Comments

What’s Hot

Top 8 upgrades every Kel-Tec Sub 2000 owner needs: MCARBO parts review
Featured

Top 8 upgrades every Kel-Tec Sub 2000 owner needs: MCARBO parts review

Why .45ACP is an outdated caliber
Ammunition

Why 45 ACP is an outdated caliber

OffHand Gear Takes AR-15 Accessories to Another Level with New Chameleon Handguard Finishes and Matching Furniture Sets
Firearms Accessories

OffHand Gear Takes AR-15 Accessories to Another Level with New Chameleon Handguard Finishes and Matching Furniture Sets

AR Build Kits under $300
Firearms Technology

Peak AR: Davidson Defense AR Build Kits under $300

Dogs

Tactipup Extreme Collar and Leash: Tactical dog gear, Perfected

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive email updates daily and to hear what's going on with us!

In Case You Missed It

Gear Reviews

A Gun to Ride the River With: The Smith & Wesson 686

October 9, 2019 Leave a Comment

Camping Gear

The MSR Pocket Rocket | Your little camp dragon

October 8, 2019 Leave a Comment

The Outdoor Edge ParaClaw: A concealed stinger
EDC

The Outdoor Edge ParaClaw: A concealed stinger

October 7, 2019 Leave a Comment

Gear Reviews

A plate carrier for the big boys: AR500’s Testudo Gen 2 is a good pick for large frames

October 7, 2019 Leave a Comment

Get it on Google Play

© Copyright 2021 Crate Club Group · All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Advertisers