• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
The Loadout Room

The Loadout Room

Professional Gear Reviews

Hardcore Gear and Adventure

Menu
  • Shooting
        • Pistol
        • Pistol Accessories
        • Rifle
        • Rifle Accessories
        • Shotgun
        • Machine Guns
        • Air Guns
        • Ammunition
        • Optics and Sights
        • Weapon Lights
        • Tips & How-To
        • Concealed Carry
        • Holsters
        • Suppressors
        • Precision Rifle Shooting
        • Firearms Training
        • Pistol in HolsterCraft Panther Holster: A No‑Drama Solution for Everyday Carry
        • CMP9-pistolCaracal CMP9 & CMP9K: Modern 9mm Platforms With Global Momentum
        • AR-15 Red DotAR-15 vs AR-10: Choosing the Right Rifle and the Right Glass
        • SIG RattlerSIG Sauer MCX Rattler CO2 BB Air Gun: Big Fun 3 Rounds at a Time
    • Close
  • Gear Reviews
      • Mission Gear
      • Camping Gear
      • Survival Gear
      • Medical Gear
      • Adventure & Travel
      • Knives & Tools
      • Overland
      • Disaster Preparedness
      • Footwear
      • Womens Gear & Clothing
        • Viking-Bags Logo 2Viking 28L Century Large Leather Motorcycle Trunk Bag: Real Capacity, Real Travel
        • RyobiBattery Power Stations: So Good, You Can Toss Your Gas Generator
        • Viking-Bags Logo 2Pic of the Day, Viking Motorcycle Bags 45L Tactical XL Bag
        • Hunting in TexasThese 5 ATV Dealers Will Get You Ready For Hunting Season in Texas
    • Close
  • Men’s Lifestyle
      • Fitness
      • EDC
      • Eyewear
      • Watches
      • Electronics & Technology
      • Downtime
      • Mens Clothing & Accessories
      • Manly Skills
      • Style & Grooming
      • Gentleman Drinks
      • Crate Club
        • Grittier Sigurd shirt 25.11 V.XI Sigurd Shirt — A Year of Real‑World Use, and Why It Works for More Than Just Operators
        • Feature Photo5.11 V.XI XTU MC Pants — Versatility You Can Work, Play, and Live In
        • Pistol in HolsterCraft Panther Holster: A No‑Drama Solution for Everyday Carry
        • CMP9-pistolCaracal CMP9 & CMP9K: Modern 9mm Platforms With Global Momentum
    • Close
  • News
  • Video Demo
  • Buying Guides
  • Shop
  • Advertise
Pistol

The 8 Pistols That Battled to Win the Army’s XM17 MHS Competition

September 12, 2017 by The Loadout Room Leave a Comment

The 8 Pistols That Battled to Win the Army’s XM17 MHS Competition

Courtesy of Tactical Life

By now you’re probably aware that Sig Sauer’s P320 won the U.S. Army’s XM17 Modular Handgun System (MHS) competition to replace the legacy M9 and M11 service handguns—mil-spec versions of the Beretta 92FS and Sig P228, respectively. Starting with the Future Handgun System (FHS) over a decade ago, which merged with U.S. Special Operation Command’s Joint Combat Pistol (JCP) program, the idea was to pick a suitable off-the-shelf replacement. This eventually led to the Army-managed MHS program.

The House Armed Services Committee pushed to cancel the XM17 MHS program and upgrade the M9 instead as a less expensive option. Attempting to appease the MHS specifications while meeting the House’s suggestions, Beretta created its M9A3 pistol upgrade after identifying engineering change proposals (ECPs) under the existing contract. However, shortly after that, reports circulated that the M9A3 had been rejected and the House of Representatives approved $5.4 million to procure 7,106 MHS-approved pistols for testing. Thus, Army Contracting Command released an official MHS request for proposals (RFP) in August of 2015, listing a program value of up to $580 million.

Depending on what source you listen to, there were up to 14 pistols from 12 manufacturers offered as contenders for the MHS program. The testing ended up being a $17 million process to find a replacement. The initial bidders for the contract included Beretta, CZ, Glock, FN, Smith & Wesson and Sig Sauer, among others.


Continue reading on Tactical Life

Photo courtesy of Tactical Life

Share This

More From The Loadout Room

Comments

Primary Sidebar

Most Read

  • Mossberg 930: the affordable 12 gauge auto-loader
    Mossberg 930: the affordable 12 gauge auto-loader
  • Smith & Wesson 327 TRR8, A Fast Shooting Wheelgun
    Smith & Wesson 327 TRR8, A Fast Shooting Wheelgun
  • Tisas 1911A1 U.S. Army Review: Best Budget .45 ACP WW2 1911 Clone?
    Tisas 1911A1 U.S. Army Review: Best Budget .45 ACP WW2 1911 Clone?
  • Mossberg Shockwave Versus Remington Tac 14
    Mossberg Shockwave Versus Remington Tac 14
  • 5.11 V.XI XTU MC Pants — Versatility You Can Work, Play, and Live In
    5.11 V.XI XTU MC Pants — Versatility You Can Work, Play, and Live In

Find Us on Facebook

The Loadout Room

Recent Comments

  • ways-of-the-qilin on Barely Legal NFA Hacks – NFA Defiance at its Finest
  • betnacional-aviator on 10 Fathers Day Gifts For Camping
  • gpu server on Triton’s Artificial Gill: Fact or Fiction?

Latest From SOFREP

War Stories

Former Navy SEAL and Delta Force Command Surgeon: How I Was Beat Down During Hell Week

News + Intel

Chinese Weapons Flow Into Iran

SOF

Philippine Scout Rangers: The Gold Standard in Jungle Survival Training

Culture

Playing It Safe Is How Future Leaders Stall Out

Military Content Group

© Copyright 2026 Military Content Group · All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Advertisers